Anna Karenina as a Feminist Character
Feminism is a collection of movements and ideologies aimed at defining, establishing, and defending equal political, economic, cultural, and social right for women. After reading this definition on Wikipedia, I couldn’t think of a single reason why Anna Karenina should be considered a feminist character, and why it should be such a popular topic of assignments and tests. If Anna was a feminist, she was an accidental one. A modern reader will not judge her on moral grounds for destroying her loveless marriage. But her capability for rational and sensible thinking is seriously in doubt. She was fully aware of how precarious her situation was. How could she ever hope to continue seeing her son in that situation? She rejected a divorce in the hope of not breaking that relationship, which even a modern reader can guess was impossible in her circumstances. In the process she rejected even the little feminist choice the circumstances were providing her with. If she were a feminist and sincerely believed herself to have the right to choose, she wouldn’t have been ashamed of herself. At the very least, she should either have had the strength to stay away from society and still be happy, or to not feel tortured at the jeering.
If there is a feminist character in the novel, I would rather say it is Karenin, Anna’s husband. The novel is not generous to him. His act of not going for a duel is considered unmanly. But what can be a more vulgar display of patriarchy than fighting a duel over a woman’s sexual life. He gives her the freedom to continue seeing her lover, if only external proprietary were maintained, and he wasn’t forced to own up the situation publicly and give divorce. The novel portrays this too as the sin of non-passion. I am inclined to think that he gave her as much freedom and choice, while still shielding her from the harm and ridicule, as the society and laws allowed him. He is the feminist character in whose portrayal the novel doesn’t do enough justice. After all, wouldn’t the male feminists of today be considered sissy in a publicly-acknowledged patriarchal society?
The assignment was much longer and had gone beyond word-limit, but Professor Siddhartha Sen read on without taking his eyes off the notebook even once. By the time he finished, a smile was playing on his lips. A smile, which if it were seen publicly, would have surprised his colleagues as well as students. He was known as a good, but an extremely demanding teacher. He wasn’t ill-tempered, but he wasn’t amiable either. In particular, he was a strict disciplinarian. He reached his class five minutes before the scheduled time, started the lecture at exactly the scheduled time, and once the lecture started, he wouldn’t allow anyone to enter the class, even if they were late only by a minute or a half. Deadlines for his assignments were similarly strict to the last minute. He collected them from his mailbox right at the deadline and even if others came in while he was still collecting them, they won’t be graded. Not even a missing comma escaped his attention while grading the tests and not failing his course was enough of an achievement even for the best of the students. And he didn’t smile.
—
Karishma’s eyes widened when she looked at the notebook returned by the teaching assistant. Mou, her best friend, peeped in almost at the same time and shrieked. “OMFG. Karishma Gupta. Ten on ten. On an English assignment? From SS of all people?”
“Hush Mou. Until I see this on the final grade-sheet, I do not believe it. I think he had intended a zero. By mistake a line has been drawn before it and it looks like ten. This is not expected of Mr. Perfectionist, is it?”
“Oh shut up, you sly creature. If you don’t want me to read you assignment, just say so.”
“Read it, if you wish. It’s not like he is going to give the same assignment again,” she carelessly flung the notebook at Mou, who caught it with some difficulty. Then she coolly reminded her, “But you would do better to rush to the class. He is giving a quiz today, do you remember?”
“Damn this continuous evaluation. And SS takes it to heart. Other professors are not so keen on giving tests every week.”
Another surprise awaited Karishma, once the test was over.
“I will need help in carrying these papers to my room. The TA is absent,” Siddhartha Sen said to nobody in particular after collecting the test papers from students.Then suddenly he looked at her, “Ms. Gupta. Would you mind carrying them?”
Karishma was too nonplussed with his request to take note of everybody’s eyes on her. The question in her mind, and in those eyes was the same, however. ‘Siddhartha Sen knows her by name?’
She got up looking dazed, picked up one stack of test papers and followed him silently to his office.
—
“There… On the right side on the desk,” he told her where to keep the papers. “You assignment was quite interesting.”
“Huh?” she was startled.
“Are you unwell? You look lost.”
“No. No… Thank you. But I am fine. I was just a little preoccupied.”
“Preoccupied?”
“There are more tests today. This continuous evaluation is getting on our nerves.”
“Well… At least, it keeps you all on your toes.”
“Keeps making us prepare for tests all the time. Leaves little time to study.”
“Ah! Students are dying to study otherwise, you mean?” he raised an eyebrow.
“I cannot speak for everyone, but even those who do want to study, cannot.”
“Hmm… Anyway. I was saying that your assignment was interestingly written. Although there is a lot of scope for debate, the originality was commendable.”
Her face flushed despite herself. It was indeed ten on ten then. She wasn’t being bashful in front of Mou. She indeed hadn’t been sure of that, having done the assignment recklessly.
“Thank you, Sir,” she managed to mumble before leaving.
Siddhartha could not suppress a smile seeing her walking away hurriedly as if bitten by something.
—
To be continued
4 thoughts on “Being Anna (Part 1)”
Heavy start… 😛 i had to hunt for dictionary to understand her assignment… ;p
I hv got a very bad vocab… 😛
Agree to above comment…
U r superb in writing mish…
Superb start ….
A teacher n student….or better a strict teacher and a carefree student….
Unique but superb combination…
Some ppl are just natural in a debate as this karishma 😀
Indeed a heavy start Mish Di..
in the very begginning i was not getting it..i thought u gave a summary of this Whole Story..as in Anna a married woman and her situation..
eagerly waiting for the next part 😉
Thank you girls. And to compensate for the heavy beginning, I posted a second part too 😛
Do you know the story of Anna Karenina?